lindsay clancy husband reddit: what happened,Murder 3 Children,mom accused

Lindsay Clancy was a mother of three young children — daughter Cora (age 5), son Dawson (age 3), and infant son Callan (approximately 8 months old) — living in Duxbury, Massachusetts. She worked as a labor‑&‑delivery nurse and reportedly had what appeared to be a stable family life with husband Patrick.

Patrick Clancy has publicly spoken of the family, saying the children and his wife were the “essence of my life.”

Thus, by most public accounts, the family seemed outwardly stable.

The Incident (January 24 2023)

On January 24, 2023:

• The children were found dead in the family home’s basement.

• The method: exercise‑bands wrapped around the necks of the children, which the prosecution alleges were used for strangulation.

• The youngest, Callan, initially survived but died a few days later in hospital.

• Investigation shows that earlier that day: the children played in the snow, the mother ordered take‑out, sent the husband on errands, all of which the prosecution uses to claim planning.

• Lindsay jumped out of a second‑floor window of the home, sustaining serious spinal injuries and being left paralyzed from the waist down.

• Patrick Clancy found his wife outside with injuries, asked “What did you do? Where are the kids?” She responded, “In the basement.” He entered and found the children and removed the bands, trying to revive them.

The evidence, as alleged by prosecutors, indicates a sequence of events that they say was premeditated.

Legal Charges & Current Status

Lindsay Clancy has been charged with multiple counts of murder and strangulation.

Her trial date has shifted; it was originally set for December 2025 and later moved to January 5, 2026.

Her defense attorney has filed a “notice of lack of criminal responsibility,” meaning the defense intends to argue that she was not criminally responsible due to a mental disorder (insanity defense).

Recently she has also filed a motion to change venue, citing prejudicial publicity in Plymouth County and requesting the trial be moved to Boston.

Husband’s Role & Public Statements

Patrick Clancy’s role in this case is critical — not only as the husband of the accused and father of the victims, but also as a public voice.

His statements

• He described returning home to the scene, finding his wife injured, and the children dead. He said:

  “I wasn’t married to a monster – I was married to someone who got sick.”

• He publicly forgave his wife and asked the public for forgiveness for her as well.

His actions in the aftermath

• He completed the Boston Marathon in honor of his three children, raising funds for Boston Children’s Hospital.

• He has assumed the role of advocating for their memory and navigating his own grief and incredibly difficult circumstances.

Husband’s public perception

Reddit threads show that many forum users express sympathy for Patrick, seeing him as a deeply traumatized victim who has suffered an unimaginable loss. One reddit post noted:

“I have a three year old and a ten month old. This was horrible to read. The mental images are horrifying and I cannot imagine what the father is enduring.”

Another thread notes how the husband has asked for forgiveness for Lindsay:

“I want to ask all of you that you find it deep within yourselves to forgive Lindsay, as I have.”

Mental Health & Medical/Medication Context

A major dimension of the case concerns Lindsay Clancy’s mental health, her postpartum status, treatment, medications, and how those may have influenced events.

Postpartum mental illness / psychosis

• The defence argues she suffered from postpartum depression and even postpartum psychosis — a rare but severe condition in new mothers.

• The defense team argues that Ms Clancy was driven to commit the murders by postpartum psychosis.

Medication / Overmedication concerns

• She reportedly took a large number of psychiatric medications in the months leading up to the incident, including antidepressants, antipsychotics, and drugs to help with insomnia.

• Some experts call this “irrational polypharmacy,” highlighting the risks of multiple psychiatric drugs.

Evidence of planning vs mental break

• Prosecutors claim she researched how long it would take the husband to pick up take‑out, chose a restaurant farther away than usual, and searched for ways to kill on her phone, arguing this shows planning.

• Some Reddit users believe she knew exactly what she was doing, while the defense argues that despite outward normality earlier in the day, she had a psychotic break according to her statement and family interviews.

Reddit & Online Commentary

Reddit and online forums reflect public debate:

• Many express horror, empathy for the father, anger or skepticism toward the mother.

• Some argue overmedication and postpartum psychosis may have played a role in her actions.

• Others are skeptical of the insanity defense, pointing to alleged evidence of planning.

• Discussions show tension between empathy for the accused mother and outrage over the act itself.

Broader Questions & Issues Raised

1. Postpartum psychosis and maternal homicide

The case highlights the rare but severe risk of maternal homicide linked to postpartum psychosis, depression, and other postpartum mental illnesses.

2. Medication management & polypharmacy

The case draws attention to managing severe mood or psychotic illnesses in new mothers, including risks of multiple medications and their interactions.

3. Planned act vs crisis act

The tension between whether the killings were premeditated or occurred during a psychotic break is legally and morally significant.

4. Role of husband and father

Patrick Clancy’s journey from victim to public figure, advocate, and grieving parent adds a human dimension that draws attention.

5. Change of venue / media coverage

The defense’s motion to move the case highlights the challenge of ensuring a fair trial in high-profile cases.

What Happened to the Husband, Patrick Clancy?

• He returned home to a scene of devastation, finding his children dead (or mortally wounded) and his wife injured.

• He has publicly asked the public to forgive his wife, stating that she “got sick” and was not a monster.

• He has memorialized his children through fundraising and running the Boston Marathon in their honor.

• Many online discussions view him sympathetically as the surviving parent.

What Is Going On Now & Upcoming Trial

• The trial date is set for January 5, 2026.

• The defense has filed a motion to change venue to Boston due to extensive media coverage.

• The defense will argue “lack of criminal responsibility” based on mental illness and medication.

• Prosecutors emphasize planning and evidence of intent.

• The sequence of events leading up to the tragedy will be central, including the timeline of morning activities, errands, and searches.

Why the Case Is Resonating — And Why the Reddit Focus

• Shock Factor: A mother allegedly killing her three young children defies assumptions about motherhood.

• Mental Health Complexity: Postpartum illness, medications, and psychosis raise questions about prevention and treatment.

• Social Media/Reddit: Detailed reporting and forum discussions amplify timelines, evidence, and debate.

• Father’s Story: Patrick’s survival and public advocacy add a human dimension.

• Legal Questions: Venue change, insanity defense, and evidence of planning make this a case study in criminal law and mental health.

Reddit discussions often revolve around reconciling evidence of planning with claims of psychosis, and debates over the appropriate level of sympathy for the accused.

Ethical, Social & Clinical Reflections

Prevention & Intervention

Could more robust screening for postpartum mental illness have changed the outcome? The case underscores the need for integrated care for new mothers.

Medication Safety

The alleged overmedication highlights risks of polypharmacy and the need for careful monitoring, though under-treatment can also pose significant risks.

Legal Responsibility vs Mental Illness

Balancing compassion for mental illness with protection of victims and accountability is central to the case. Evidence of planning complicates the narrative of a psychotic break.

Social Media & Public Judgment

Online forums amplify discussion but can oversimplify the nuances of mental illness, medication, and legal responsibility. Patrick Clancy’s voice emerges as a central and sympathetic focus.